Groom+Style is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
Home » Best Shaving Soap For 2021
Your guide to this review is Lisa Fitzgerald

Best Shaving Soap For 2021

Shaving Soap Reviews

Col. Conk Shave Soap 2.25 Ounces (Variety 4 Pack)
Maison Lambert Shaving Soap - Shaving Soap - Shave Soap - Organic Shaving Soap - with Argan Oil and Jojoba Oil to Protect Your Skin! 4 Oz (Cedarwood)
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Proraso Shaving Soap In A Bowl - Refresh, 5.2 oz
Mitchell's Wool Fat Shave Refill Soap
Our Rating
9.6
9.4
9.2
9.0
8.7
MSRP
$12.40
$19.95
$11.99
$10.00
$14.75
Size
2.25 Ounce (Pack of 4)
4 Oz
Pack of 3 (10.5 Oz)
7 Oz
4.4 Oz
Ingredients
With Avocado and Vitamin E
All Natural - Vegan - Handmade
Cocoa Butter - Smooth and Irritation-Free
Eucalyptus Oil With Menthol
Natural Lanolin Content of Wool Fat
Color
Multi-colored
Cedarwood
White
White
White
Col. Conk Shave Soap 2.25 Ounces (Variety 4 Pack)
Our Rating
9.6
MSRP
$12.40
Size
2.25 Ounce (Pack of 4)
Ingredients
With Avocado and Vitamin E
Color
Multi-colored
More Information
Maison Lambert Shaving Soap - Shaving Soap - Shave Soap - Organic Shaving Soap - with Argan Oil and Jojoba Oil to Protect Your Skin! 4 Oz (Cedarwood)
Our Rating
9.4
MSRP
$19.95
Size
4 Oz
Ingredients
All Natural - Vegan - Handmade
Color
Cedarwood
More Information
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Our Rating
9.2
MSRP
$11.99
Size
Pack of 3 (10.5 Oz)
Ingredients
Cocoa Butter - Smooth and Irritation-Free
Color
White
More Information
Proraso Shaving Soap In A Bowl - Refresh, 5.2 oz
Our Rating
9.0
MSRP
$10.00
Size
7 Oz
Ingredients
Eucalyptus Oil With Menthol
Color
White
More Information
Mitchell's Wool Fat Shave Refill Soap
Our Rating
8.7
MSRP
$14.75
Size
4.4 Oz
Ingredients
Natural Lanolin Content of Wool Fat
Color
White
More Information

Every boy dreams of becoming as responsible as their father, and part of growing up with a dad is emulating what they do. Even the little things as a standing posture or walking style, a boy gets that from their father or father figure in their lives.

When boys get to teenagehood, the first person they look up to for advice regarding their physical changes is the dad. And how to shave is lesson 101 a boy should get from their dad.

So what happens if you, the dad, big brother, uncle, or grandfather, have no idea how to shave? Let alone the best shaving soap?

Where do you expect this young man to learn from? Well. Wonder no more as this piece will teach you how to use shaving soap and even offer you a list of the best shave soap.

But before we get to these products below, here are a few helpful tips for the best shaving soaps. It has a brief description of what makes a good shaving soap, what you need to shave using soap, and lastly, why you need one.

What Makes a Good Shaving Soap

They should have ingredients that nourish both the skin and the facial hair

vintage set for shaving

An exceptional shaving soap must be made of elements that make your skin smooth and soft after a shave. A soap that dries you after a shave is not only bad for your skin but the hairs inside the skin.

You should get one that opens up the skin pores to avoid ingrown hair, resulting in skin bumps. That said, pick soaps with moisturizing constituents like glycerin and fat. These elements are not only moisturizing but also act as lubricants for a smooth shave.

A commendable shaving soap should match your skin type

Every person has different skin types, which will result in getting one that is best for you. You will find soaps good for oily skin, others dry, regular, and sensitive skin. Therefore, here is why you should take the time to study your facade and know your skin type.

After learning this, go ahead and get the soap that best fits you. Do not worry; it may cost you nothing—use the internet to your advantage and get informed of the best shaving soap to use.

It should lather faster

Lastly, a shaving soap bar must show sud fast. This is to minimize time and save on its usage as well. A fast foaming soap will help lubricate the skin and reduce the likelihood of you cutting your skin using a razor.

Items You Need for Shaving Using the Top Shaving Soaps

There are essentially three things you need for shaving, and they are water, best shaving soap for safety razor, and a brush. And beard to shave of course. And below is how to go about shaving your beard using the best shaving soaps:

  • First, you wet the brush bristles by running it under a stream of warm water. It is best to use a badger brush or organic bristles soft and gentle on the skin.
  • After the strands have absorbed water, rub some of the water on your beard to hydrate them before you start shaving.
  • The next thing is to sud up the soap to get a thick cloud of soap and use the brush to massage the soap on your beard.
  • Use a razor or shaver to remove the hair by firmly holding the device to your skin to entirely cut the hair follicles at the lowest point of the hair protrusion. If you have the best shaving soap, you will not need to re-lather the cloud.

Why You Need the Best Shaving Soap

The answer to this question is rather apparent; everyone wants a clean and smooth feel after a shave, and that is why using the best comes in. You also want to have hydrated skin, and on top of that, smell divine.

Hopefully, the following best shaving soap products will get you all that plus more. Read on to find out more.

Best Overall: Colonel Conk Shave Soap

Colonel Conk Shave Soap Review

Check​ Price on Amazon

This collection of soaps is the best as it has four different sorts under the same brand of shaving soaps. As the overall best shaving soap, it has quite a rich history that involves Colonel Conk falling in love with a lady who shaved men’s beards and ended up tying the knot with her. Soon after, they started a barbershop enterprise as a team.

His dream of shaving products for men to ease shaving effortlessly started there and has grown bigger and better. Even after his death, the idea of creating a shaving soap brand was kept alive.

Soap features

The Colonel Conk shave bar comes in four distinct scents- the Bay Rum, lime, almond, and amber. Each bouquet is immaculately organized to deliver a gentle sillage of masculine aromas that are subtle and not overwhelming.

The Bay Rum is a blend of bay leaves and Jamaican rum, while the rest smell like the respective sources. They are formulated with other ingredients like avocado and Vitamin E, which are great for the skin afterward.

It has plenty of glycerin, which is instrumental as a lubricant for a clean, smooth shave. Unfortunately, some of the ingredients are not natural; thus, it is not entirely organic. One puck may weigh either 2.25 ounces or 3.75 ounces.

Advantages

  • The fragrances of these shaving soap bars are exceptional and distinctive.
  • You get a sound cloud of foam in just a few swabs.
  • The smooth slickness is commendable.

Disadvantages

  • The formulation contains a few synthetic elements.

This shaving soap is best for

It is an excellent and the best shaving soap for all wet shavers. Anyone who enjoys the right thick cloud lubricated shave and a long-lasting and well-scented puck, then this is the best for them.

It is ideal for all skin types but has the best results when used on normal skin. To apply, you will need a brush. The puck comes in a clam-shaped vessel, but you may need an extra container to lather the bar. The pack of four retails at $14.

Runner Up: Maison Lambert Shaving soap

Maison Lambert Shaving soap Review

Check​ Price on Amazon

If you are not particularly fond of scented shaving soaps, then the Maison Lambert is the pinnacle on the list of the top shaving soaps that are all-natural and non-scented. This shaving soap is gentle on the skin, making it the best shaving soap bar for all skin types but mainly the sensitive kinds.

Soap features

As mentioned before, Maison Lambert shaving soap is entirely natural and thus is considered a vegan shaving soap. It contains argan and jojoba oil, which are great for moisturizing skin.

It also includes hints of cocoa butter to smoothen out skin after a shave. Aloe vera is also in the mix. The essential oils in the cedarwood-colored shaving bar soap are lavender, cedarwood, lime, and rosemary.

Advantages

  • The blend of ingredients is top-tier.
  • This shaving soap lathers creamy and lubricating foam, which qualifies as the best shaving soap for razor safety.
  • It is the perfect soap for sensitive skin prone to outbreaks and cuts since it has mild ingredients that do not mess with the skin’s natural oils.

Disadvantages

  • The lack of a distinct scent gives it a medicinal smell some people don’t like.
  • It takes longer to lather than ordinary shaving soap.

This soap is best for

The Maison Lambert is quintessential for lads with allergy-prone skin and those who prefer vegan and natural hair and skincare regimes. You will require a soft-bristled brush for a clean application so that you keep the puck for a more extended period.  One 40 Oz bar goes for only $20.

Alternative: Van Der Hagen Scented Shaving Soap

Van Der Hagen Scented Shaving Soap Review

Check​ Price on Amazon

This version is one of two; the other kind is the unscented bar soap. This piece is a superior brand but still pocket-friendly because they come in budget packs. For one package, you will obtain three 3.5 Oz circular bars.

Soap features

This piece of heaven contains glycerin, mango, cocoa, and shea kinds of butter. Each of these elements has a known track record to proffering skin a velvety and silky aftermath sensation. The aroma is a citrusy smell that is not overpowering at all. The scent is light and fresh, which is mild and energizing.

Advantages

  • The bland aroma is enchanting to many people.
  • The constituents utter this shaving product as one of the top-tier soap for a smooth and spotless shave.
  • It is an economical pick that gives you excellent service for little cost.
  • It suds a substantial amount of lather, which provides smooth and even shaving.
  • It is easily accessible.

Disadvantages

  • The soap is only available in one scent, which can be boring for someone who appreciates mixing it up.

This soap is best for

It is the perfect and the best shaving soap for people who are not extravagant about getting a product but still want a top-tier piece. The Van Der Hagen scented version is also quintessential for a guy who relishes the citrusy fragrance and does not mind wearing it as his signature scent, besides his cologne.

The lubrication is optimal as the outcomes are cut free and soft and velvety to touch. One budget pack retails for $19 for three 3.5 Oz circular bars.

Alternative: Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso Shaving Soap Review

Check​ Price on Amazon

This is an alternative pick, but it is still recommended on most shaving soap reviews. It is an Italian brand with a relatively long shelf duration that will serve you for a few months.

Soap features

This soap weighs 2.5 oz, and one puck used sparingly at least once a day could last you about five months or more. There are two wonderfully blended aromas, the Eucalyptus and menthol. This combo oozes out the freshness and energizing opening up the nasal cavity for easier breathing. Besides the refreshing advantage, the Eucalyptus is renowned for its skin-toning benefits and closing the skin pores. This makes the skin appear younger, elastic, and gleaming.

The formula does not contain mineral oil nor silicon; thus can be best for easily irritable skins.

Advantages

  • The long lifespan makes this product economical.
  • The luscious suds make shaving easier since it lubricates and proffers an effortless and clean shaving experience.
  • It is available in a multitude of scents.
  • It can be utilized as the preferred shaving soap for all skin kinds.
  • The elements are significant players to ensure your skin remains moisturized and healthy after.

Disadvantages

  • If you do not cover the lids adequately, the soap might dry up and break.

This shaving is best for

Any gentleman who enjoys a gentle scent of fresh Eucalyptus or menthol can go for this pick. It retails for approximately ten-dollars and can be applied to any skin type. If you do love to have a clean-shaven face, bump, and cut-free, then you better get yourself one.

Alternative: Mitchell’s Wool Fat

Mitchell's Wool Fat Review

Check​ Price on Amazon

The formula was created and made a debut in 1930 by a chemist called Fred Mitchell. This brand is made in England but has roots in Scotland.

Soap features

One puck of the Mitchell wool fat shaving soap is approximately 3 inches in diameter. If you use this product once a week, you are guaranteed usage for about five months. It contains natural lanolin, which is gotten from sheep. It is a very potent moisturizer to dry skin and hair.

Therefore, by using this product, your skin becomes hydrated, and the hair that grows back is healthy too. Whether you want a beard or not, it still becomes healthy. Unfortunately, this product is not all-natural as it has a few synthetic ingredients. This piece’s fragrance is very basic; there is nothing special besides a spice hint from afar.

Advantages

  • The lengthy span is economical for anyone on a tight budget.
  • The skin becomes healthier and looks fresh and young after and beyond usage.
  • It is a shaving soap bar for people with allergies to strong-smelling soaps.

Disadvantages

  • It takes a while longer to sud, and the foam may start to dwindle if left untouched after about 45 seconds.

This shaving soap is best for

Any man who likes having clear, moisturized skin after shaving without spending a lot could benefit from the Mitchell wool fat shaving soap. The only disclaimer to proffer is that you should stay away from this shaving bar soap if you are allergic to any sheep product. It has a selling price of approximately $16.

Shaving Soap FAQ

What does shave soap do?

benefits of shaving soap

Shave soap has one main job— to support and ensure a velvety, cut, and bump-free shaving experience for any man or boy.

Secondly, banking on the constituents, shaving soap should leave the skin moisturized and proffer more beneficial properties like toning and tightening skin pores. They are also skin cleaning agents.

Can I use shaving soap as regular soap?

Yes, you can, but it isn’t recommended. Some formulations could be very concentrated, only modeled to be used once a week at most, and if used daily, could cause more harm than good.

Sure, both soaps lather up similarly, although regular soap has a thinner sud and a brief life span too. That said, if you use shaving soap for regular soap, then you would be wasting it.

Thirdly, if the fragrance is strong, using it every day might cause respiratory disturbances in the nasal cavity. In conclusion, shaving soap is not equipped to clean like regular soap has been fashioned to achieve. So yes, you may use it, but be aware of the consequences after.

Is shaving cream better than soap?

whipped shaving soap

The answer will lie with the person using either of the two products. But here are the comparisons:

When it comes to foaming, shaving cream does it faster only because it already has water in the formula. On the flipside, bar soaps take longer, but their foam lasts longer too.

However, that will depend on the brand of the bar soap you would be using. The best shaving soaps will produce long-lasting foam that will lubricate your hair-cutting session.

Shaving creams are more versatile to bar soaps. They can shave the beard, armpits, and other hairy places, including the back and legs. If you dare use bar soap, you might use more and take a very long time in the process.

Using the best soap shaving products will require more time and more items for the exercise. You will need water, a shaver, a razor or machine, a brush, and the bar soap.

For the cream, you only need water, the cream, and a razor. The brush is optional, and you may or may not need it.

That said, cream shaving products are more of a faster solution as you apply, shave, rinse, and go. Whereas bar soap shaving products are wet, lather, massage, shave, rinse, and go. Those extra steps take time.

Both have unique properties to offer the skin, but the selection of which is better than the other is dependant on the user’s preferences. Their prices are in a vast range, and so what you select will depend on your shaving technique, choice, and mostly your budget.

How long does shave soap last?

soaps for shaving

This will depend on three things: the puck’s size, how often you use it, and the brand.

If you have a puck that is about 2.5 oz and you use it once a week, then it may last you close to four months, nearing the fifth month. Anything larger would last you longer. Suppose you use that same bar twice a month, and maybe you are sharing it with someone else, then the duration is cut in half.

When it comes to the brand, certain soaps take longer while others take a short time. And this is due to either the process of manufacturing or the ingredients used.

Nevertheless, it is a factor that may dictate how fast the soap wastes away. If it takes longer to lather, it merely means that you have to swab multiple times more to get the desired sud thickness. A bar soap that lathers faster only uses a small portion thus will last longer.

Conclusion

If you have been looking for a soap that will sort out all your skin issues like bumps after shaving, cuts, dryness, and itching, then one of the products above might help you out. Here is a pro-tip, get one mild formula if you are prone to skin allergies, and escalate slowly from there.

After reading this, getting the best shaving soap for men should be hard. You should pick one of the products described and try it out. Indeed each has its perks and downsides, but the unfavorable are things you can find a way around. If you look at it from another perspective, you even have more than five options to go for.

For instance, Con. Conk has four different scents, and each is unique to the next. So you cannot use the excuse that nothing fits you. It will help if you try then judge after.

Well, you might not be a man or have a son, but sure you might have a brother, father, uncle, boyfriend, or friend who would not mind getting a gift to begin a new year with a new product in their grooming set. It is a well-thought-of gift that you might have never thought of. But now, you have an idea. Purchase one or two for them.

shares